In academia who would self-report anything else?

I have just received a note from a journal that my article will not be included in a forthcoming overview of one of the world’s great economists (now sadly deceased).

I am sorry to inform you that your proposal has not been selected for inclusion in the special issue. There were many excellent proposals, including some with significant overlap with yours. We have decided to go with a few more historically oriented pieces by young scholars.

The probability that someone else will be writing on Say’s Law approaches nil, but I suspect this is a form-letter sent out to everyone whose proposals were rejected. Nothing new here for me. I mention it really only to draw attention to the above chart. Economics is in the blue columns on the right, but they’re all more or less the same no matter what the discipline (although economics is a bit better than the others). These are the social sciences where you would expect this kind of outcome, but I wonder how different it would look for physics and chemistry.

The chart is from THE GEEK IN PICTURES at Powerline which has a number of equally interesting charts about the world we inhabit.

Proving by the absence of a contrary argument why Donald Trump should be re-elected

These independent columnists at The Oz are for the most part a pretty shallow lot when it comes to discussing American politics. There are not one but two anti-Trump articles today. I read all such articles religiously wherever they show up, since I am in an ongoing pursuit of the contra case which has been utterly invisible up until now. There is, of course, no case for Biden, But after four years of his presidency, there must be an anti-Trump case somewhere. But if there is, you won’t find it in The Australian.

This is Peter Van Onselen’s take, who, he writes, “seriously toyed with renouncing his [American] citizenship four years ago when Trump won”. I’ll bet. Just like all the folks who threatened to move to Canada. From what he has written today, he is obviously unable to have learned anything since 2016. Here’s what he has to say four years later: US election 2020: For decency’s sake, Trump must not be returned. Why then is that?

“The damage four more years of Trump would do to American society, its standing in the world, the Republican Party and conservatism as an ideology isn’t worth thinking about…. His mocking of people’s looks, gender, sexual orientation and those with a disability makes him unfit to run a corner shop much less a country…. The cause of conservatives will continue to drift further from what conservatism is supposed to represent: a defence of institutions and respect for process and good governance.

“[There is] his ongoing (near endless) personal abuse of anyone who challenges him. His profound mishandling of the COVID crisis. Despite the way Trump threatens to tear down institutions and denigrate the fourth estate at every opportunity. All the while bringing American democracy into disrepute….

“[There is also] Trump’s flippant attitude towards the dangers COVID-19….

“Trump has never been about anything other than his own aggrandisement. But the way so-called conservative commenta­tors and politicians have abided Trump, even spruiked for him, is much harder to forgive. Doing so exposed how shallow their collective beliefs and ideological understanding really is.

There it is. That’s the case. If anyone can find anything else, they are welcome to add it in. Especially absurd is his telling conservatives what to believe as if he has even an inkling of a notion what conservatism is. How do people like that get paid real money to write such trash?

There is then the equally dense Troy Bramston in his US election 2020: Voters are tired of Trump’s catastrophic presidency. Same challenge, to find anything of substance from one end of the column to the other. Not that there is much effort made to make such  case. The entire article is about polling and how Trump is almost certain to lose which he may well do, in large part because of the full court press all across the media. These are, in full, his reasons why he ought to lose.

Trump has been a catastrophic president….

The most important election issue is COVID-19. Trump’s handling of the pandemic has been disastrous.

Both are an embarrassment to The Australian and to journalism. The Murdoch Press is gung ho in opposing Trump’s re-election. Their columnists have apparently followed the boss’s orders in trying to make the invisible case for voting for Joe Biden instead. What their writings show beyond anything else is that no such case exists because if it did, someone would be able to make it.

Grifters and crooks, father and son

I have been waiting for this to show up in a more prominent way and now it has. The more interesting question is whether it matters. Obviously it does in some sense, since the Friends of the Democrats (ie the mainstream media + social media) have done all they can to prevent any of it becoming an election issue. Still, there is this.

The three tweets are from here: President Trump: Bidens Are ‘Grifters,’ ‘Crooks’. And so they are. But for a Democrat, it does not appear to matter. These people give democracy a bad name.

Australians watching American politics according to the NYT

If you have had any doubts about the quality of insights found in the New York Times, they can now be put to rest: Australians Watching American Politics: ???!!!!***$%%#. Here’s how it starts:

Australians used to talk about American politics the way they talk about sport — they followed the ups and downs, marveled at the competitor, and tried to game out who would win.

This year? It’s more like the discussion of a car wreck involving a neighbor or an uncle.

For months, friends and even strangers have been asking if my relatives are healthy, worried they may have perished in the American coronavirus catastrophe. And this week, after a debacle of a debate and the news that President Trump and Melania Trump had tested positive for the coronavirus, I saw and heard more than just empathy — also shock, dismay, fear, heartbreak and just head-shaking alarm.

Van Badham, a commentator who often writes for The Guardian (and occasionally the New York Times Opinion section), replied to my tweet about Mr. Trump’s positive test result with what many Australians seem to be feeling:

“I just
I can’t
I mean
What
Oh god”

My very reaction and so well put. All the news that’s fit to be ignored.

Might also add in this from Paul Krugman on the NYT editorial page: Trump Is Killing the Economy Out of Spite. So much to choose from but this will have to do:

Last year Donald Trump called Nancy Pelosi, the House speaker, a “nasty, vindictive, horrible person.” Actually, she isn’t — but he is.

Trump’s vindictiveness has become a major worry as the election approaches. He has already signaled that he won’t accept the result if he loses, which seems increasingly likely though not certain. Nobody knows what chaos, possibly including violence, he may unleash if the election doesn’t go his way.

Even aside from that concern, however, a defeated Trump would still be president for two and a half months. Would he spend that time acting destructively, in effect taking revenge on America for rejecting him?

Well, we got a preview of what a lame-duck Trump presidency might look like Tuesday. Trump hasn’t even lost yet, but he abruptly cut off talks on an economic relief package millions of Americans desperately need (although as of Thursday he seemed to be backtracking). And his motivation seems to have been sheer spite.

Why do we need economic relief? Despite several months of large employment gains, America has only partly recovered from horrific job losses in the early months of the pandemic — and the pace of recovery has slowed to a relative crawl. All indications are that the economy will remain weak for many months, maybe even years.

How long it takes for recovery to be complete, in spite of all the employment gains already, will depend on who wins the election. Obama-Biden couldn’t effect a recovery following the GFC although they had eight years to try. Not in a single year did the economy grow faster than three percent! You know Einstein’s definition of political insanity about continuing with policies that fail. I only hope we are not given the opportunity to find out for ourselves as the Democrats once again try their Keynesian economic magic.

It is certainly October and this was definitely a surprise

This was supposed to be the first debate of three but we are now into unknown territory. Where the debates will go from here, where anything will go from here, is an unknown. To be asymptomatically struck with the Chinese flu will allow the President to continue his duties to an extent, and will certainly allow him to speak even if not in public. For virtually everyone who gets it, CV-1984 is not a debilitating disease. If it comes and goes, as it should, the end of the lockdowns will be hastened.

So far as understanding politics, it has often been remarked that those on the left are unable to understand we on the opposite side. But I have to say, I do not understand the left at all. The agenda remains purely insane to me: socialism, Green New Deal, Black Lives Matter, anti-white, anti-Western Civilisation, anti-capitalist, open borders. None of these makes the slightest coherent sense, to me. Everything sought will, as I see it, only make the world a much worse place than it is today. The nearest I can see to the end in mind is California as it has become, which is a nightmare horror. Anyway, below are a further set of discussion on the debate the other night, but I have to say that by now it has drifted far into the farthest reaches of our present concerns and the direction of public debate as the American election approaches.

President Trump Discusses First Presidential Debate With Sean Hannity…

Two October Surprises The Democrats Can’t Do Anything About

Joe Biden’s Vacant Debate (And Eyes)

Enough of the Ridiculous White Supremacy Question, Why Hasn’t the Media Asked Biden to Rebuke BLM/Antifa?

The Proud Boys Have a Black Leader

Biden feigned anger to dodge question | Dana Loesch

Trump’s biggest victory of the debate | Bill O’Reilly

Second Presidential Debate Moderator Steve Scully Interned in Joe Biden’s Senate Office

Black Proud Boys leader: We’re not white supremacists, ‘as you can see’

BOMBSHELL: Joe Biden was clearly WIRED during the debate… see images from video here

IT BEGINS: Pelosi Pushes Biden to Abandon Next Two Debates, Says ‘ONE AND DONE!’

TRUMP on DEBATES: ‘Why Would I Allow the Commission to Change the Rules When I Won the Last Time?’

Leader of ‘white supremacist’ Proud Boys is state director of unofficial support group called Latinos for Trump and has ties to Republicans including the president’s son Don Jr., Senator Ted Cruz and Roger Stone, who is a member

Proud Boys, Black Lives Matter leaders hold joint conference: We ‘denounce White supremacy’

The Trump-Biden Stakes: Your Life Savings

McEnany RIPS Media For Ignoring Trump’s Frequent Denunciation of White Supremacists

Biden digs his own grave in ninety minutes

Trump up in first post-debate poll, ‘on the rise again’

CNN Claims Biden Debate ‘Largely Accurate.’ Here Are 14 False Claims By Biden.

Trump DOMINATES First Debate Against FLEDGLING Biden as Left MELTS DOWN!

Further reflections on the first debate

The mainstream media is filled with as many liars as the Democrat Party, is totally untrustworthy in passing on the news, but more importantly cannot be trusted to interpret events. Below are more reflections on the first debate from the conservative side [here are the first set] which provide straightforward explanations as we would see it, and no doubt as most observers saw it whose madness has not distorted their view of the world.

What is there to be said about people who defend putting to the torch major cities such as Seattle, Portland and Minneapolis? Crazy, yes, but there is a psychological derangement so bizarre that no one may ever work it out. Are these people sick at heart to find that socialism doesn’t work and that it is capitalism provides wealth and security? Do they really believe there is some alternative means of creating communities that will provide better conditions and individual happiness? Are these people so deranged that they believe that we really must throw over all of our forms of power generation right now to save us from an environmental catastrophe in fifty years time? Do they actually think we who are the least racist communities which have ever lived can create more harmony through armed and violent division? Who knows? I just think they are crazy, but what help is it to know that if they steal the election and put their mates in charge? Anyway, here are amplifications of what the President said during the debate that again emphasise how crucial this election really is.

The Debate Segment on Race Was Appalling and Not Because of President Trump

Rush Limbaugh: Joe Biden, Chris Wallace Were ‘Ganging Up’ on Donald Trump

Joe Biden is Not a Nice Man and He Hasn’t Been Nice to Israel

Democrats’ only path to victory: Violence, smears and cheating

Joe Biden and Chris Wallace Started It by Interrupting Trump Numerous Times First

Biden and the ‘No Wrongdoing’ Mantra

Biden claims Senate report about son getting $3.5 million ‘discredited’

Debate Commission Decides Chris Wallace Was an Insufficient Tool

Biden Falsely Claims Antifa Is an Idea, Not an Organization

Biden and the ‘No Wrongdoing’ Mantra

Facebook Regulatory Counsel Joins Biden Transition Team As Zuckerberg Commits To Silencing Trump Victory Claims

Chris Wallace Knows Better than to Let Biden Get Away With These Four ‘Whoppers’Hell Freezes Over: The New York Times Fact Checks Biden On The Economy, Rates His Claim As ‘False’

Brazil’s President Lights Up Joe Biden After Ridiculous Threat

Journalists Covering Antifa Blast Joe Biden: People Aren’t Being Assaulted in the Streets by an ‘Idea’

Yes, Trump has a health care plan — he has been implementing it

TRUMP: ‘We Won the Debate, Biden Looked Very Weak, He Was Whining’

[Nigel] Farage Bashes Biden On ‘Biggest Lie’ About AntiFa

CHRIS WALLACE, AMERICAN MEDIA FIDDLE DURING DEBATE AS BLM, ANTIFA BURN OUR COUNTRY

Presidential Debate Number One: A Biden Fact-Check

The Pandemic On Biden’s Watch Killed 13 Times As Many Children As COVID

CNN claims Biden never called Trump xenophobic for China travel ban … Here’s a tweet for you, CNN

Civilised societies do get put to the torch from time to time by their own citizens. We are looking at the madness of crowds and the formation of our own modern Committees of Public Safety.

The debate showed Trump is the greatest political genius of our time

Donald Trump is perhaps the greatest political genius of all time. That he became President in 2016 and is still in the running to be re-elected in 2020 given all of the opposition from the media, from every facet of the left and especially the screwball left (is there any other kind at the moment?), from many within his own party, from within the bureaucracy, from state governors who are willing to burn down their cities to defeat him in November, from the Chinese who let loose a deadly pandemic, to the Democrat governors and Democrat politicians generally who used the Chinese virus as a political weapon, from the election cheating that will be a major part of the Democrat election program, given all of these you still cannot count him out.

The debate was a case in point. These are all posts of one sort and another about how PDT neutralised all of this during the Presidential debating with Joe Biden, but also simultaneously debating with the moderator. Do not lose heart is the central message here.

Here Are The 11 Dumbest, Most Slanted Questions Asked By Chris Wallace

See some of the best memes that came out of last night’s presidential debate

CIVIL WAR AT FOX NEWS? Ingraham, Gutfeld, Others Attack Chris Wallace After Debate

JOE CLAMS UP: Biden Claims Russian Payment to His Son Hunter ‘Has Been Discredited’

Trump Corrects Biden: ‘Don’t Ever Use The Word ‘Smart’ With Me’

Your Obligatory Trump-Biden Debate Post

FACT CHECK: Did Hunter Biden Get Kicked Out of the Military for Drugs? (Spoiler: Yes) [Updated]

Trump’s Funniest Moments During the Grudge Match Debate

Trump Goes After Joe Biden Over Son’s Role At Ukrainian Energy Firm, $3.5 Million Wire Payment

Joe Biden’s debate “wire” video goes viral

VP Biden helped son Hunter become fabulously wealthy by shaking down international governments and corporations

NYT readers in rebellion, ‘canceling subs’ en masse after unfavorable Biden fact-check tweet

Contrary To His Debate Claim, Biden’s Own Website Says He Supports The Green New Deal

Trump Goes After Joe Biden Over Son’s Role At Ukrainian Energy Firm, $3.5 Million Wire Payment

Liberals upset Biden does not support Green New Deal

Biden Told So Many Whoppers Last Night, Burger King May Sue Him

Moderator Chris Wallace Interrupted Donald Trump 76 Times, Biden 15 Times

Chris Wallace Just Gave The Most Embarrassing Moderator Performance In History

Trump Tells Biden to His Face ‘I’ve Done More in 47 Months Than You’ve Done in 47 Years’